PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
#31
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jul 2017
Location: Algarve
Posts: 569
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
Received a letter to go to the local Finaças up here in the north with supporting documents.
I did but no one there could understand English at all. I showed them the letter but all I got was waving of hands and they did not even look at the docs I gave them.
A person waiting in the queue said to me that they are saying I must come back with my accountant. My accountant is in the deep south so I phoned her and handed the phone to the guy. After about 30 minutes of haggling he gave the phone back and waved his arms some more.
My accountant sent me an email the same day but I could not understand what she was trying to say.
Very frustrating and I have been looking for a local accountant that speaks English but there are none. Off to a remote Siberian island hut to hide from this.
I did but no one there could understand English at all. I showed them the letter but all I got was waving of hands and they did not even look at the docs I gave them.
A person waiting in the queue said to me that they are saying I must come back with my accountant. My accountant is in the deep south so I phoned her and handed the phone to the guy. After about 30 minutes of haggling he gave the phone back and waved his arms some more.
My accountant sent me an email the same day but I could not understand what she was trying to say.
Very frustrating and I have been looking for a local accountant that speaks English but there are none. Off to a remote Siberian island hut to hide from this.
#32
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Aug 2012
Location: Viana do Castelo
Posts: 1,385
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
Our Finanças is not very friendly. There is a machine at the entrance with buttons to get a ticket to enter but I cannot figure out what button to press so I press any button. My number gets called up and the guy says something in Portuguese and waves his arms. So I just go home again.
#33
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
Our Finanças is not very friendly. There is a machine at the entrance with buttons to get a ticket to enter but I cannot figure out what button to press so I press any button. My number gets called up and the guy says something in Portuguese and waves his arms. So I just go home again.
I have few good words for the finanças, but they are no different to any other bureaucrats in Portugal. If you behave as you suggest here and EXPECT them to speak to you in English, whilst making no effort yourself, you'll not get far. Many Portuguese are no diffferent to you, they might speak a little English, but not enough, so they don't try. Make an online translation, print it and take it with you - it will be wrong, but at least you'll have made an effort....
Otherwise, your only option is to request an English speaker or an interpreter - and/or pay for a Portuguese speaking agent to speak for you. You might be lucky - but not in a local office, only at one of the regional centres.
#34
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 970
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
Your attitude when visiting finances helps, ask and ask, preferably in your limited Portuguese and you'll more than likely find that people will help.
The finances in Olhao was a nightmare years ago., kept moving offices for various things - car tax was in one office one year, another the next. We always asked and were helped. One bloke even gave us his place in the queue.
Here, in Ourique, we're blessed with lovely, understanding people. Only had one long wait but more than happy with them. Helpful and friendly.
The finances in Olhao was a nightmare years ago., kept moving offices for various things - car tax was in one office one year, another the next. We always asked and were helped. One bloke even gave us his place in the queue.
Here, in Ourique, we're blessed with lovely, understanding people. Only had one long wait but more than happy with them. Helpful and friendly.
#35
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 1,829
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
Our Finanças is not very friendly. There is a machine at the entrance with buttons to get a ticket to enter but I cannot figure out what button to press so I press any button. My number gets called up and the guy says something in Portuguese and waves his arms. So I just go home again.
#36
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jan 2011
Location: Tunbridge Wells KENT
Posts: 2,914
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
A Portuguese resident is liable to tax on his worldwide income/gains/profits. "Out of Portugal" income (such as income/gains from foreign real estate) will usually be taxed in the foreign country first and Portugal second. The relevant double taxation treaty and the NHR scheme may provide some reduction in the rates of tax(es) that will actually be charged on some specific forms of income etc but they do not offer an automatic across-the-board tax holiday.
The surest way to guarantee zero tax is to have zero income.
The surest way to guarantee zero tax is to have zero income.
I have already told him that I happen to have pension income from a country that does not have a double-taxation treaty with Portugal so it is my understanding that this will be taxable in some way but what I am hoping for is something very similar to the overall HMRC tax position as below, which comes from the make-up of tax due when one files an HMRC UK tax return under self-assessment.
This brings all the income together, deducting allowances and giving the final tax due. I would think/hope that this could be provided as a standard template for what must be a fairly typical make-up of annual income for those considering NHR apart from that Foreign Income
Profit from UK land and property £X,XXX.00
Foreign income* £X,XXX.00
Dividends from foreign companies ** £X,XXX.00
Interest from UK banks, building societies and securities etc £XXX.00
Dividends from UK companies £X,XXX.00
UK pensions and state benefits *** £X,XXX.00
UK and US Capital Gains
*State and Employment Pension Income from a non-double taxation treaty jurisdiction
** USA - double taxation treaty
*** Purely UK State Pension
Presumably one would have to provide hard evidence to support the taxable income figures and one also needs to ADD/INCLUDE any income and capital gains in ISAs
Providing the make-up of all income for UK tax purposes is pretty darned onerous and it would be nice to escape this under NHR but I'm not sure what the Portuguese authorities typically need - aside from the known initial financial position.
If it is a serious grind indeed - does it make sense to become residents? as opposed to going up to six months per tax year as a non-resident
Last edited by Pistolpete2; Nov 19th 2017 at 7:24 am.
#37
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
I went through a similar process, trying to figure out the tax implications of foreign income and getting frustrated with web based information that always seemed to assume I was in a certain category that I'm not.
Tax laws and their application is often counter-intuitive, and when you're a multinational person you really need a specialist, even when your income level is quite moderate.
Make an appointment, bring your paperwork and sit down for an hour with a person who knows this stuff, like Denis Swing-Green over at Eurofinesco.
Then you can do your sums and make these very important decisions. Don't forget to factor in the cost and quality of health care in whatever scenario you're considering; this is really important, and often treated as an afterthought as people get all excited about climate and scenery.
I've sat down and consulted with tax experts from 3 different countries, multiple times. a few hundred Euros in fees VERY well spent.
Tax laws and their application is often counter-intuitive, and when you're a multinational person you really need a specialist, even when your income level is quite moderate.
Make an appointment, bring your paperwork and sit down for an hour with a person who knows this stuff, like Denis Swing-Green over at Eurofinesco.
Then you can do your sums and make these very important decisions. Don't forget to factor in the cost and quality of health care in whatever scenario you're considering; this is really important, and often treated as an afterthought as people get all excited about climate and scenery.
I've sat down and consulted with tax experts from 3 different countries, multiple times. a few hundred Euros in fees VERY well spent.
#38
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jan 2011
Location: Tunbridge Wells KENT
Posts: 2,914
Re: PORTUGAL, does it make sense to become residents?
I went through a similar process, trying to figure out the tax implications of foreign income and getting frustrated with web based information that always seemed to assume I was in a certain category that I'm not.
Tax laws and their application is often counter-intuitive, and when you're a multinational person you really need a specialist, even when your income level is quite moderate.
Make an appointment, bring your paperwork and sit down for an hour with a person who knows this stuff, like Denis Swing-Green over at Eurofinesco.
Then you can do your sums and make these very important decisions. Don't forget to factor in the cost and quality of health care in whatever scenario you're considering; this is really important, and often treated as an afterthought as people get all excited about climate and scenery.
I've sat down and consulted with tax experts from 3 different countries, multiple times. a few hundred Euros in fees VERY well spent.
Tax laws and their application is often counter-intuitive, and when you're a multinational person you really need a specialist, even when your income level is quite moderate.
Make an appointment, bring your paperwork and sit down for an hour with a person who knows this stuff, like Denis Swing-Green over at Eurofinesco.
Then you can do your sums and make these very important decisions. Don't forget to factor in the cost and quality of health care in whatever scenario you're considering; this is really important, and often treated as an afterthought as people get all excited about climate and scenery.
I've sat down and consulted with tax experts from 3 different countries, multiple times. a few hundred Euros in fees VERY well spent.
I was thinking that as a UK State Pensioner I would be able to avail myself of the existing scheme where the NHS gets re-billed since apparently that is the only deal that has so far been accomplished by the DD crew. My admittedly thoroughly disillusioned GP in the UK said that using the Portuguese public health system would be a step-up.
I've looked at the issue of care in Portugal and thought the custom-built facilities west of Faro rather expensive and would need to dig deeper. We were of a mind to CREATE our own small care facility in the Caribbean to meets our/my needs and maybe a couple of others in due course but I've gone off that idea of late even though we would be below what is known as the Hebert Hurricane Box and the Hurricane Navigation Box.
Last edited by Pistolpete2; Nov 19th 2017 at 8:13 am.