How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
#1
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 3
How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
My girlfriend is applying for a work visa in New Zealand but has received an
e-mail saying that it will not be granted on the grounds she is taking a kiwis job. We have until the 6th to prove other wise. She is a support worker caring for the disabled. Her Employer is currently very understaffed and has been advertising for workers for at least 8 months. They advertise on trade me, seek and in the local paper. They also have their details singed up to wingz but they rarely get sent any workers and if they do they're no good. According to immigration there are people who can do the job or be trained to do the job in the hawks bay area but in almost the year my girlfriend has been working there they haven't had any one prepared to do the work required.
Can anyone think of any other ways to prove she is not taking a job from a kiwi?
e-mail saying that it will not be granted on the grounds she is taking a kiwis job. We have until the 6th to prove other wise. She is a support worker caring for the disabled. Her Employer is currently very understaffed and has been advertising for workers for at least 8 months. They advertise on trade me, seek and in the local paper. They also have their details singed up to wingz but they rarely get sent any workers and if they do they're no good. According to immigration there are people who can do the job or be trained to do the job in the hawks bay area but in almost the year my girlfriend has been working there they haven't had any one prepared to do the work required.
Can anyone think of any other ways to prove she is not taking a job from a kiwi?
#2
MODERATOR
Joined: Oct 2011
Location: Wellington - I miss Castles, the NHS & English school system
Posts: 9,077
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
The employer needs to prove that they have done sufficient advertising to employ someone already with the appropriate visa not your gf. It is down to the employer.
If she is already working there what visa is she on at the moment?
Are her skills not on the skills shortage lists?
If she is already working there what visa is she on at the moment?
Are her skills not on the skills shortage lists?
#3
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jul 2013
Location: Christchurch
Posts: 570
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
When my employer did that for me (as MrsF says it's their job not yours) they provided photocopies of all employment advertisements etc. to evidence they'd tried. If they have a HR department at their company this could be something to ask them about.
#4
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 3
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
She is currently on a working holiday visa and no her job is not on the skilled shortage list. She is working very closely with her employer who also can't think of anything else they can do.
#5
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 3
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
We have already sent copy's of all advertisements they currently run and we also have sent a letter from the CEO of her company which states they have tried everything and how much they need her.
#6
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2003
Location: North Shore, Auckland
Posts: 688
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
Sounds like you and the employer have done everything you can do already.
The issue will be that there will be unemployed people in your area who could and should do the work - but won't because they don't fancy it.It is an ongoing problem for a job like that - there are lots of unemployed people who could be filling the vacancy but would rather sit back and take the handout instead.
The issue will be that there will be unemployed people in your area who could and should do the work - but won't because they don't fancy it.It is an ongoing problem for a job like that - there are lots of unemployed people who could be filling the vacancy but would rather sit back and take the handout instead.
#7
MODERATOR
Joined: Oct 2011
Location: Wellington - I miss Castles, the NHS & English school system
Posts: 9,077
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
I can see that you say they get sent workers, the fact that they are no good, doesn't really come into it they are able to source locally from what you suggest. Has the Company spoken to Immigration and put their case? Don't know if it would help.
What visa is you GF on at the moment?
What visa is you GF on at the moment?
#8
Forum Regular
Joined: Apr 2014
Location: Sydney / Christchurch
Posts: 192
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
Care giver and a work visa
I wish you the very best of luck
What visa are you on by the way? How long have you two been together?
Companies like Bupa and Oceania struggle to employ because of the work conditions and the dreadful pay. There was an article in the Herald a few weeks ago (i'll see if I can find it), that the popular members of staff in these places are partners of skilled migrant or wtr migrants. It's generally the pay that puts people off working there, I think the average wage is the minimum wage to around $16 unless you are a resident nurse.
There is nothing that you can really do about this. It will be down to the company of the care home to do this. From my understanding, they try to avoid doing this because of the costs and also they don't understand immigration rules. If she could get the boss or the employer to contact the case officer and ask what they need to do, to satisfy INZ, that's the best way forward.
How we do it at our place, is that we do the usual advertisements and then we provide INZ with applications or enquiries from whatever site we've used or if they've come via our work site. We kept records of the date our advert was placed internally and externally to when the migrant applicant applied. The Kiwi issue wasn't a problem for us. We showed INZ some of the applicants CVs who applied against the migrant we wished to hire. Then it was all down to whether INZ accepted our proposal why we wished to hire Mr Migrant instead of any Kiwi. This was a pain in the backside for us, therefore we became accredited (it is so much easier to employ migrants when accredited).
I wish you the very best of luck in this by the way
I wish you the very best of luck
What visa are you on by the way? How long have you two been together?
Companies like Bupa and Oceania struggle to employ because of the work conditions and the dreadful pay. There was an article in the Herald a few weeks ago (i'll see if I can find it), that the popular members of staff in these places are partners of skilled migrant or wtr migrants. It's generally the pay that puts people off working there, I think the average wage is the minimum wage to around $16 unless you are a resident nurse.
There is nothing that you can really do about this. It will be down to the company of the care home to do this. From my understanding, they try to avoid doing this because of the costs and also they don't understand immigration rules. If she could get the boss or the employer to contact the case officer and ask what they need to do, to satisfy INZ, that's the best way forward.
How we do it at our place, is that we do the usual advertisements and then we provide INZ with applications or enquiries from whatever site we've used or if they've come via our work site. We kept records of the date our advert was placed internally and externally to when the migrant applicant applied. The Kiwi issue wasn't a problem for us. We showed INZ some of the applicants CVs who applied against the migrant we wished to hire. Then it was all down to whether INZ accepted our proposal why we wished to hire Mr Migrant instead of any Kiwi. This was a pain in the backside for us, therefore we became accredited (it is so much easier to employ migrants when accredited).
I wish you the very best of luck in this by the way
#9
Nz
Joined: Mar 2012
Location: Canterbury
Posts: 368
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
she cant but the employer can!
#10
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Sep 2009
Location: thatcham berkshire england
Posts: 432
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
My girlfriend is applying for a work visa in New Zealand but has received an
e-mail saying that it will not be granted on the grounds she is taking a kiwis job. We have until the 6th to prove other wise. She is a support worker caring for the disabled. Her Employer is currently very understaffed and has been advertising for workers for at least 8 months. They advertise on trade me, seek and in the local paper. They also have their details singed up to wingz but they rarely get sent any workers and if they do they're no good. According to immigration there are people who can do the job or be trained to do the job in the hawks bay area but in almost the year my girlfriend has been working there they haven't had any one prepared to do the work required.
Can anyone think of any other ways to prove she is not taking a job from a kiwi?
e-mail saying that it will not be granted on the grounds she is taking a kiwis job. We have until the 6th to prove other wise. She is a support worker caring for the disabled. Her Employer is currently very understaffed and has been advertising for workers for at least 8 months. They advertise on trade me, seek and in the local paper. They also have their details singed up to wingz but they rarely get sent any workers and if they do they're no good. According to immigration there are people who can do the job or be trained to do the job in the hawks bay area but in almost the year my girlfriend has been working there they haven't had any one prepared to do the work required.
Can anyone think of any other ways to prove she is not taking a job from a kiwi?
#11
Re: How do I prove I'm not taking a job from a kiwi
My employer wrote me a statement and provided evidence of all the previous advertisement campaigns and that was sufficient.