Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
#46
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
Hello fellow Expats
Appreciate thoughts on my dilemma. I'm resident in the UAE and fully (Double dose) vaccinated with Sinopharm from earlier this year plus had a booster of Pfizer one month ago in Cleveland Clinic AUH.
I have the option to get the second dose of Pfizer and i'm sitting on the fence. Contentious issue if it is medically advisable to get a double dose of Pfizer on top of double Sinopharm and that's not my question. (Personally i think the risk/ benefit is sub optimal and a little risky).
My main dilemma is if there is any travel advantage now or potential in the future to being double jabbed with Pfizer (administered in the UAE)? Currently it seems the UK is only recognising approved vaccines administered in the UK, US or select European countries so no real advantage at the moment and would be treated as essentially unvaccinated and requiring quarantine if i return home from the UAE. Appreciate your thoughts and insights and best guesses into the possible travel benefits?
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/red-ambe...ber-list-rules
TIA
Appreciate thoughts on my dilemma. I'm resident in the UAE and fully (Double dose) vaccinated with Sinopharm from earlier this year plus had a booster of Pfizer one month ago in Cleveland Clinic AUH.
I have the option to get the second dose of Pfizer and i'm sitting on the fence. Contentious issue if it is medically advisable to get a double dose of Pfizer on top of double Sinopharm and that's not my question. (Personally i think the risk/ benefit is sub optimal and a little risky).
My main dilemma is if there is any travel advantage now or potential in the future to being double jabbed with Pfizer (administered in the UAE)? Currently it seems the UK is only recognising approved vaccines administered in the UK, US or select European countries so no real advantage at the moment and would be treated as essentially unvaccinated and requiring quarantine if i return home from the UAE. Appreciate your thoughts and insights and best guesses into the possible travel benefits?
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/red-ambe...ber-list-rules
TIA
#47
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
Dutch police recently fired live rounds into a crowd of protestors over similar rulings coming into play.
To my knowledge, we don't jail people who don't get the usual round of childhood jabs because they work and have a long track record...and they work so well that we generally only need about 75% of the population to have them to achieve herd immunity.
With these new jabs, we have countries like Israel, Ireland and areas like Gibraltar that have well over 90% double jab rates going back to lockdown restrictions and calls are going out for a third jab or even regular jabs like a flu jab.
I'm still waiting to find out why I need to be in fear of the unvaccinated, label them all as looneys and support calls to fine, sack or jail them. If my jabs worked why do I care if others don't get it as is their human right to refuse any medical procedure they will and accept any consequences as a result?
N.
#48
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2017
Location: Dubai
Posts: 851
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
They are becoming mandatory in some parts of the world. Austria is has stated they will fine people who refuse a vaccine, and if they don't pay the fine they will be jailed.
Dutch police recently fired live rounds into a crowd of protestors over similar rulings coming into play.
To my knowledge, we don't jail people who don't get the usual round of childhood jabs because they work and have a long track record...and they work so well that we generally only need about 75% of the population to have them to achieve herd immunity.
With these new jabs, we have countries like Israel, Ireland and areas like Gibraltar that have well over 90% double jab rates going back to lockdown restrictions and calls are going out for a third jab or even regular jabs like a flu jab.
I'm still waiting to find out why I need to be in fear of the unvaccinated, label them all as looneys and support calls to fine, sack or jail them. If my jabs worked why do I care if others don't get it as is their human right to refuse any medical procedure they will and accept any consequences as a result?
N.
Dutch police recently fired live rounds into a crowd of protestors over similar rulings coming into play.
To my knowledge, we don't jail people who don't get the usual round of childhood jabs because they work and have a long track record...and they work so well that we generally only need about 75% of the population to have them to achieve herd immunity.
With these new jabs, we have countries like Israel, Ireland and areas like Gibraltar that have well over 90% double jab rates going back to lockdown restrictions and calls are going out for a third jab or even regular jabs like a flu jab.
I'm still waiting to find out why I need to be in fear of the unvaccinated, label them all as looneys and support calls to fine, sack or jail them. If my jabs worked why do I care if others don't get it as is their human right to refuse any medical procedure they will and accept any consequences as a result?
N.
#49
Forum Regular
Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 147
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
Herd immunity estimate is 93-95% for MMR
if 25% remain unvaccinated against Covid (assuming an age spread) then your health system will collapse, which should bother everyone.
if 25% remain unvaccinated against Covid (assuming an age spread) then your health system will collapse, which should bother everyone.
#50
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,520
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
Having COVID antibodies seems to be the most effective set of antibodies, so I dare say it's just a matter of time till the unvaccinated get herd immunity and things calm down. I'm vaccinated but I don't buy into this hysterical fear over the unvaccinated nor the same fear about collapsing health care systems in developed nations.
New drugs are going to be released in a few months that should end this silly argument. But the political war against the unvaccinated is something that won't be forgotten.
#51
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2017
Location: Dubai
Posts: 851
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
suppose it depends what you consider to be a collapsing healthcare system …… spend some time talking to a few frontline healthcare professionals who were working long hours 7 days a week to the point of exhaustion keeping people alive during the hospitalisation peaks in the UK ….. you might change your view about how little it would take for a system to collapse.
#52
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,520
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
suppose it depends what you consider to be a collapsing healthcare system …… spend some time talking to a few frontline healthcare professionals who were working long hours 7 days a week to the point of exhaustion keeping people alive during the hospitalisation peaks in the UK ….. you might change your view about how little it would take for a system to collapse.
Last edited by DXBtoDOH; Nov 24th 2021 at 4:36 pm.
#53
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2017
Location: Dubai
Posts: 851
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
Never did, did it? I don't make light of the matter but people should tread carefully before doing something so radical against many people's free will. I'm cold enough to say if someone refuses vaccination and gets sick enough then they deserve the troubles heaped on their own head, but that would be a result of their own decisions. This type of aggressive behaviours towards a minority rarely works out well in the long run.
Don’t get me wrong I’m against anyone being forced to vaccinate but I’m not against everyday life being made difficult if someone simply chooses not to be.
#54
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
without getting into an ‘Anti Vax’ debate ….. it’s not just about the impact on you and them (the unvaccinated) …. Isnt it also partly about the strain on any given healthcare system and the risks posed to those who are vulnerable through no fault of their own ? Too many people in this world only think of me me me.
Given the low morbidity rates for covid and low hospitalisation rates for younger people and people without co-morbidities I am not sure gaslighting, denigrating, fining, sacking and now jailing people who are low risk who decide they don't want to take the jab (and those who have natural immunity...which lasts longer and works better seem to being forced to take it as well) is the way forward.
The worst forms of tyranny always start with "It's for your own good".
#55
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
How many of that 25% will even need to see a doctor is the magic question.
We know vaccinated people can spread it, need treatment and die from it as well. We are witnessing that right now in Israel, Gibraltar and Ireland - who all have a higher rate of double vaccination that the herd immunity estimates you gave.
We also know that lockdown restrictions have questionable outcomes - Florida vs California come to mind as immediate examples.
#56
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
Ireland - approx 8% of the population over 12 are unvaccinated. The hospitals are reporting 50 to 60% of patients presenting with Covid are unvaccinated, so the vaccinated are hugely under represented.
#57
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
Never came close to collapsing in any developed nations, outside maybe a few weeks in Italy in the early days.
Having COVID antibodies seems to be the most effective set of antibodies, so I dare say it's just a matter of time till the unvaccinated get herd immunity and things calm down. I'm vaccinated but I don't buy into this hysterical fear over the unvaccinated nor the same fear about collapsing health care systems in developed nations.
New drugs are going to be released in a few months that should end this silly argument. But the political war against the unvaccinated is something that won't be forgotten.
Having COVID antibodies seems to be the most effective set of antibodies, so I dare say it's just a matter of time till the unvaccinated get herd immunity and things calm down. I'm vaccinated but I don't buy into this hysterical fear over the unvaccinated nor the same fear about collapsing health care systems in developed nations.
New drugs are going to be released in a few months that should end this silly argument. But the political war against the unvaccinated is something that won't be forgotten.
I can go to work and travel without proving I don't have ebola, rubella, measles, strep throat, cold and flu (which are fatal in vulnerable group and really do burden healthcare systems in the winter especially), chicken pox, shingles and many other diseases, some of which have much higher mortality rates than covid. The demonisation of people who refuse vaccines and the rush supposedly free nations are in to create a vaccine apartheid is certainly something many people seem comfortable with - just as many were comfortable with the persecution of certain groups in the 20th century who were also blamed for the world's problems by politicians who caused the problems in the first place.
I cannot think of a single instance in history where people who throw what amounts to blood libels against another group, and who seek to separate them from society, deny their rights and persecute them end up on the right side of history,
#58
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
I wouldn't call those numbers a huge under representation. I'd call it "about half" - which suggests these vaccines are about as effective as seasonal flu vaccines - rather than as effective as the polio vaccine and other jabs we often get as children.
#59
Forum Regular
Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 147
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
So 40% to 50% of people needing to go to hospital are vaccinated then.
I wouldn't call those numbers a huge under representation. I'd call it "about half" - which suggests these vaccines are about as effective as seasonal flu vaccines - rather than as effective as the polio vaccine and other jabs we often get as children.
I wouldn't call those numbers a huge under representation. I'd call it "about half" - which suggests these vaccines are about as effective as seasonal flu vaccines - rather than as effective as the polio vaccine and other jabs we often get as children.
The 8% of unvaccinated people are providing half the hospitalisations, the 92% are providing half.
That does not equate to 50% efficacy, obviously.
It means over 90% protection again hospitalisation.
Last edited by shiraz1; Nov 25th 2021 at 5:02 am.
#60
Forum Regular
Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 147
Re: Pfizer - Booster or Fully Vaccinated Dilemma
The 8% get to hold the country to ransom, while simultaneously posing as the victims.