UK election June 8
#16
Re: UK election June 8
Neither of those things happened.
About 37% of the electorate said they wanted to leave political union, if they were lied to enough about NHS funding.
The Tories were very clear in their 2015 manifesto that even if we did that, they would preserve the place in the single market. The Leave campaign also emphasised at the time that, in the words of key campaigner Dan Hannan, "Absolutely nobody is talking about threatening our place in the Single Market".
Whilst I concede the europhobes have shown no connection to any of truth, reality, or consistency, any claim that there was a vote to leave the market is a simple, flat out lie.
About 37% of the electorate said they wanted to leave political union, if they were lied to enough about NHS funding.
The Tories were very clear in their 2015 manifesto that even if we did that, they would preserve the place in the single market. The Leave campaign also emphasised at the time that, in the words of key campaigner Dan Hannan, "Absolutely nobody is talking about threatening our place in the Single Market".
Whilst I concede the europhobes have shown no connection to any of truth, reality, or consistency, any claim that there was a vote to leave the market is a simple, flat out lie.
#17
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Feb 2014
Location: Done with condescending old hags
Posts: 1,194
Re: UK election June 8
Sorry to burst your fantasy with the real world!
We may yet lose our political rights yes, but doing so was explicitly contingent on protecting our economic ones. Any reversal of this requires a new mandate, which a desperate Chairman Maybe is now seeking, so she can sell us down the river to the lowest bidder.
Fortunately for us here, we've mostly got our Canadian lifeboats from the land of Brexit hell.
We may yet lose our political rights yes, but doing so was explicitly contingent on protecting our economic ones. Any reversal of this requires a new mandate, which a desperate Chairman Maybe is now seeking, so she can sell us down the river to the lowest bidder.
Fortunately for us here, we've mostly got our Canadian lifeboats from the land of Brexit hell.
#18
Re: UK election June 8
Sorry to burst your fantasy with the real world!
We may yet lose our political rights yes, but doing so was explicitly contingent on protecting our economic ones. Any reversal of this requires a new mandate, which a desperate Chairman Maybe is now seeking, so she can sell us down the river to the lowest bidder.
Fortunately for us here, we've mostly got our Canadian lifeboats from the land of Brexit hell.
We may yet lose our political rights yes, but doing so was explicitly contingent on protecting our economic ones. Any reversal of this requires a new mandate, which a desperate Chairman Maybe is now seeking, so she can sell us down the river to the lowest bidder.
Fortunately for us here, we've mostly got our Canadian lifeboats from the land of Brexit hell.
#19
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Feb 2014
Location: Done with condescending old hags
Posts: 1,194
Re: UK election June 8
This is about democracy, among many other things - and 37% voting to strip 100% of the people of their political and economic rights does not a reasonable demand make.
Once our democracy has been reduced, with the UK surrendering our elected MEPs, and our government having a vote in Brussels, that will do nothing to improve the UK's self-determination. End of.
#20
Re: UK election June 8
You posited a lie which I corrected (your false claim that a majority of the electorate had decided to do something which the winners categorically ruled out before the vote).
This is about democracy, among many other things - and 37% voting to strip 100% of the people of their political and economic rights does not a reasonable demand make.
Once our democracy has been reduced, with the UK surrendering our elected MEPs, and our government having a vote in Brussels, that will do nothing to improve the UK's self-determination. End of.
This is about democracy, among many other things - and 37% voting to strip 100% of the people of their political and economic rights does not a reasonable demand make.
Once our democracy has been reduced, with the UK surrendering our elected MEPs, and our government having a vote in Brussels, that will do nothing to improve the UK's self-determination. End of.
Those who didn't vote only have themselves to blame.
#21
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Feb 2014
Location: Done with condescending old hags
Posts: 1,194
Re: UK election June 8
There are for sure non-voters who regret it (and leave voters who immediately afterwards said they were only trying to send a message, and never thought it would happen). I'll happily blame them for their actions, just as I will the Quitlings for actively trying to rip us out.
None of which changes that multiple senior figures at the head of the Leave campaigns promised that "nobody is threatening our place in the single market", "Only a madman would actually leave the Market", "Increasingly, the Norway option looks the best for the UK" (inside the single market - EEA). So please don't lie that people voted for that, when the vote was explicitly made on the promise that if people voted for Leave, that would definitely not happen.
(Oh, and on numbers - yes. 52% of 72% does not a majority make. A plurality voted to leave political union, conditional on the economics being protected).
None of which changes that multiple senior figures at the head of the Leave campaigns promised that "nobody is threatening our place in the single market", "Only a madman would actually leave the Market", "Increasingly, the Norway option looks the best for the UK" (inside the single market - EEA). So please don't lie that people voted for that, when the vote was explicitly made on the promise that if people voted for Leave, that would definitely not happen.
(Oh, and on numbers - yes. 52% of 72% does not a majority make. A plurality voted to leave political union, conditional on the economics being protected).
#22
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 670
Re: UK election June 8
"The referendum was held on Thursday 23 June, 2016, to decide whether the UK should leave or remain in the European Union. Leave won by 51.9% to 48.1%. The referendum turnout was 71.8%, with more than 30 million people voting." BBC
Those who didn't vote only have themselves to blame.
Those who didn't vote only have themselves to blame.
Given no one yet knows what brexit means, other than brexit means brexit, and the real true cost of it, it really can't have been a vote for anything and everything including a whole range of contradictions and make-belief.
Final say referendum is the best way to sort it out. If we get that, I don't really care so much about the GE, as much as I'd love to see the tories out.
#23
Re: UK election June 8
But it was advisory. To be binding it really would have required a supermajority,
Given no one yet knows what brexit means, other than brexit means brexit, and the real true cost of it, it really can't have been a vote for anything and everything including a whole range of contradictions and make-belief.
Final say referendum is the best way to sort it out. If we get that, I don't really care so much about the GE, as much as I'd love to see the tories out.
Given no one yet knows what brexit means, other than brexit means brexit, and the real true cost of it, it really can't have been a vote for anything and everything including a whole range of contradictions and make-belief.
Final say referendum is the best way to sort it out. If we get that, I don't really care so much about the GE, as much as I'd love to see the tories out.
#24
Re: UK election June 8
I don't see how this election can end well.
If May has a clear win she'll take that as a mandate leave the EU, dismantle the NHS, lead the country to penury. It seems an unlikely outcome but then so did a Trump win.
If Corbyn, well nevermind, his campaign will be as much of a shambles as his government might be. He has no chance.
If May loses to the SNP in Scotland, to Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland and retains about the same number of seats in England and Wales she'll lead a weakened government in a negotiation for which it has no mandate. So that'll just result in delay and confusion.
I suppose it might be an exciting result for the fringe parties.
If May has a clear win she'll take that as a mandate leave the EU, dismantle the NHS, lead the country to penury. It seems an unlikely outcome but then so did a Trump win.
If Corbyn, well nevermind, his campaign will be as much of a shambles as his government might be. He has no chance.
If May loses to the SNP in Scotland, to Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland and retains about the same number of seats in England and Wales she'll lead a weakened government in a negotiation for which it has no mandate. So that'll just result in delay and confusion.
I suppose it might be an exciting result for the fringe parties.
#25
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 670
Re: UK election June 8
I don't see how this election can end well.
If May has a clear win she'll take that as a mandate leave the EU, dismantle the NHS, lead the country to penury. It seems an unlikely outcome but then so did a Trump win.
If Corbyn, well nevermind, his campaign will be as much of a shambles as his government might be. He has no chance.
If May loses to the SNP in Scotland, to Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland and retains about the same number of seats in England and Wales she'll lead a weakened government in a negotiation for which it has no mandate. So that'll just result in delay and confusion.
I suppose it might be an exciting result for the fringe parties.
If May has a clear win she'll take that as a mandate leave the EU, dismantle the NHS, lead the country to penury. It seems an unlikely outcome but then so did a Trump win.
If Corbyn, well nevermind, his campaign will be as much of a shambles as his government might be. He has no chance.
If May loses to the SNP in Scotland, to Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland and retains about the same number of seats in England and Wales she'll lead a weakened government in a negotiation for which it has no mandate. So that'll just result in delay and confusion.
I suppose it might be an exciting result for the fringe parties.
And so it continues...
#26
Re: UK election June 8
If Corbyn, well nevermind, his campaign will be as much of a shambles as his government might be. He has no chance.
If May loses to the SNP in Scotland, to Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland and retains about the same number of seats in England and Wales she'll lead a weakened government in a negotiation for which it has no mandate. So that'll just result in delay and confusion.
I suppose it might be an exciting result for the fringe parties.
If May loses to the SNP in Scotland, to Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland and retains about the same number of seats in England and Wales she'll lead a weakened government in a negotiation for which it has no mandate. So that'll just result in delay and confusion.
I suppose it might be an exciting result for the fringe parties.
Last edited by Almost Canadian; Apr 18th 2017 at 8:14 pm.
#28
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Nov 2003
Location: Formally Scotland. Now Bay of Quinte...Ontario
Posts: 2,466
#30
Re: UK election June 8
That Corbyn seems to be intending to fight this election on the basis of austerity, and not Brexit, shows just how out of touch he is.
I don't understand Theresa May. Considering she was near neutral on Brexit, she has suddenly become an extreme Brexiteer, despite the narrowly decided referendum, and subsequent doubts on pre-referendum promises.
I don't understand Theresa May. Considering she was near neutral on Brexit, she has suddenly become an extreme Brexiteer, despite the narrowly decided referendum, and subsequent doubts on pre-referendum promises.