Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
#91
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
But that's not the case. Tax is paid on income from the Duchy of Cornwall, after deduction of "official expenditure" in much the same way as any other landowner deducts expenses from tax liabilities. The only significant difference is that the NAO does not audit those expenses nor the tax paid - in that regard, I would agree that there is a case for an external audit of the tax situation, but it is absolutely a matter of public record (and has been since the Duchy was granted to Charles in 1969) that income tax is paid on the estate income.
Last edited by Oakvillian; Nov 29th 2017 at 3:24 pm. Reason: missed out a word
#92
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
No, the point is that they go to great lengths to describe it as a private estate when it isn't. The spin is saying that they're not funded by the nation.
#93
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
If I owned a substantial portion of land that had been handed down through family generations, why would I give it up?
I think its good that they are putting the land to good use, what else would anyone do with the land? and lets not forget that the that is only part of the Duchy of Cornwall, a lot of it comes from financial investments too.
#95
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
My father didn't buy the farm he inherited from his parents either (who in turn, inherited it from my great-grandparents), does that mean you think he should have given it up to share with everybody else as well then?
#98
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
But it's not untaxed, that's the point. £4.4 million a year is a pretty hefty tax bill by anybody's standards surely?
My father didn't buy the farm he inherited from his parents either (who in turn, inherited it from my great-grandparents), does that mean you think he should have given it up to share with everybody else as well then?
My father didn't buy the farm he inherited from his parents either (who in turn, inherited it from my great-grandparents), does that mean you think he should have given it up to share with everybody else as well then?
#99
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
There is a problem there in that the only way people can become farmers is to inherit farms and the people who inherit farms are obliged to be farmers. That may not make the best use of the land or the talents of the people involved. However, it's not obvious to me that there's a better arrangement so the best we can hope is that the people who have farming thrust upon them make a good job of it. Like Princes.
#100
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
There is a problem there in that the only way people can become farmers is to inherit farms and the people who inherit farms are obliged to be farmers. That may not make the best use of the land or the talents of the people involved. However, it's not obvious to me that there's a better arrangement so the best we can hope is that the people who have farming thrust upon them make a good job of it. Like Princes.
#101
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 516
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
Yes. I have been tussling with this a little bit. She seems a bit awkward, Diana style , though I am loathe to write that.
A part of me feels that Chelsy Davy was likely 'the one' but she did not wish to have the 24/7 365days intrusions where your life is actually not your own to live .
I believe they remain good friends.
A part of me feels that Chelsy Davy was likely 'the one' but she did not wish to have the 24/7 365days intrusions where your life is actually not your own to live .
I believe they remain good friends.
#104
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
I am very pleased for them they seem very well suited. I just hope that nothing from her past (when she was a struggling actress) comes back to haunt them, the gutter press will be relentless in there efforts to find something, remember Andrew and Koo Stark?
#105
Re: Go for it Harry marry Meghan.
I do. It is about time the RF stopped meddling in relationships. Koo Stark has proved to be in a different league to Ferguson...she has never spilled the beans on her affair with Air Miles Andy. Unlike his unscrupulous, money grabbing ex wife. IMO they should have allowed Charles to marry Camilla when they were young. If they had done so perhaps Diana would be happily married and still alive now. Same applies to Princess Margaret and Townsend.