Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
#31
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
As one of the previous posters stated "Ausweispflicht" only means that every German over the age of 16 must have an identity card. There is no "Mitführpflicht" in Germany and, therefore, no requirement to carry an identity card with you.
http://www.rechtslexikon-online.de/Ausweispflicht.html
http://www.rechtslexikon-online.de/Ausweispflicht.html
Yes it is true...you have to have am ID but you don't have to carry it around
#33
Just Joined
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 4
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
in the UK if a copper asks yhou for your name and address
just answer, AM I OBLIGED TO GIVE YOU THOSE DETAILS OFFICER?
if he/she says yes then they are commiting fraud as you do not have to make joinder with them, unless u have broken the law
should be our right to go whevever we wish without being harrassed by officers of the law
i have been stopped on my bike in germany (control, control!) i spoke in english to them, they waved bye and drove off lol!!!!
i would really like to know if it is compulsury or not, as many Germans i have found out are not sure about it, but most just follow orders (still have not learnt there lesson from 1930/40's) just to keep the status quo.
i wonder if there is common law in germany?
just answer, AM I OBLIGED TO GIVE YOU THOSE DETAILS OFFICER?
if he/she says yes then they are commiting fraud as you do not have to make joinder with them, unless u have broken the law
should be our right to go whevever we wish without being harrassed by officers of the law
i have been stopped on my bike in germany (control, control!) i spoke in english to them, they waved bye and drove off lol!!!!
i would really like to know if it is compulsury or not, as many Germans i have found out are not sure about it, but most just follow orders (still have not learnt there lesson from 1930/40's) just to keep the status quo.
i wonder if there is common law in germany?
Last edited by majorlee; Sep 21st 2009 at 10:53 am.
#34
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
And then you make a whole you world of sh!t for yourself as they cart you off to the local police station and screw your day up for you whilst they make further enquiries
#35
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: May 2009
Location: Alicante province
Posts: 5,753
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
It's true that, unlike other Europeans countries, you don't need to carry any identification documents in the UK and you could refuse to answer any questions when stopped by a police officer.
What do you think would happen next? The worst scenario would see you locked up for at least 24 days under the terrorist legislation.
What's the least unpleasant thing that could happen? You would, of course, be arrested and taken in for questioning. As an unidentified suspect, possibly an illegal immigrant, the police could take your fingerprints and DNA samples, and you would have to wait around for a bit.
If you were a real tough nut, and obstinate enough, the charge sheet presented to the court at some stage would read: Unidentified male – charged under some legislation to protect UK citizens from people who disturb Her Majesty's Peace.
You're much better off found without papers in Germany, the UK police are a lot stricter.
What do you think would happen next? The worst scenario would see you locked up for at least 24 days under the terrorist legislation.
What's the least unpleasant thing that could happen? You would, of course, be arrested and taken in for questioning. As an unidentified suspect, possibly an illegal immigrant, the police could take your fingerprints and DNA samples, and you would have to wait around for a bit.
If you were a real tough nut, and obstinate enough, the charge sheet presented to the court at some stage would read: Unidentified male – charged under some legislation to protect UK citizens from people who disturb Her Majesty's Peace.
You're much better off found without papers in Germany, the UK police are a lot stricter.
#36
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
in the UK if a copper asks yhou for your name and address
just answer, AM I OBLIGED TO GIVE YOU THOSE DETAILS OFFICER?
if he/she says yes then they are commiting fraud as you do not have to make joinder with them, unless u have broken the law
should be our right to go whevever we wish without being harrassed by officers of the law
i have been stopped on my bike in germany (control, control!) i spoke in english to them, they waved bye and drove off lol!!!!
i would really like to know if it is compulsory or not, as many Germans i have found out are not sure about it, but most just follow orders (still have not learnt there lesson from 1930/40's) just to keep the status quo.
i wonder if there is common law in germany?
just answer, AM I OBLIGED TO GIVE YOU THOSE DETAILS OFFICER?
if he/she says yes then they are commiting fraud as you do not have to make joinder with them, unless u have broken the law
should be our right to go whevever we wish without being harrassed by officers of the law
i have been stopped on my bike in germany (control, control!) i spoke in english to them, they waved bye and drove off lol!!!!
i would really like to know if it is compulsory or not, as many Germans i have found out are not sure about it, but most just follow orders (still have not learnt there lesson from 1930/40's) just to keep the status quo.
i wonder if there is common law in germany?
Charming...for somebody who is new to the forum and if you would have read the answer before you would by now have the answer to the question if it is
compulsory or not
#37
Banned
Joined: Aug 2007
Location: the dry part of Washington State
Posts: 1,333
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
in the UK if a copper asks yhou for your name and address
just answer, AM I OBLIGED TO GIVE YOU THOSE DETAILS OFFICER?
if he/she says yes then they are commiting fraud as you do not have to make joinder with them, unless u have broken the law
should be our right to go whevever we wish without being harrassed by officers of the law
i have been stopped on my bike in germany (control, control!) i spoke in english to them, they waved bye and drove off lol!!!!
i would really like to know if it is compulsury or not, as many Germans i have found out are not sure about it, but most just follow orders (still have not learnt there lesson from 1930/40's) just to keep the status quo.
i wonder if there is common law in germany?
just answer, AM I OBLIGED TO GIVE YOU THOSE DETAILS OFFICER?
if he/she says yes then they are commiting fraud as you do not have to make joinder with them, unless u have broken the law
should be our right to go whevever we wish without being harrassed by officers of the law
i have been stopped on my bike in germany (control, control!) i spoke in english to them, they waved bye and drove off lol!!!!
i would really like to know if it is compulsury or not, as many Germans i have found out are not sure about it, but most just follow orders (still have not learnt there lesson from 1930/40's) just to keep the status quo.
i wonder if there is common law in germany?
The Police in England and Germany have ways of getting their own way - so barrack room lawyers beware or you will end up like so many amateurs who tried to mix it with professionals who are used to dealing with the 'urban myth' crowd every day
Drinking dishwater tea out of a chipped enamel cup is no fun and not worth the bravado
#38
Account Closed
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 383
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
I'm sure that there is not one country anywhere where you can tell a police officer to mind his own business if he asks your name.
#40
Account Closed
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 383
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
Does everyone in Germany have some sort of a social security number which every legal resident remembers by heart?
#42
Banned
Joined: Aug 2007
Location: the dry part of Washington State
Posts: 1,333
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
That was a tasteless joke by the way - I love Germany apart from the 'boiled pigs knuckles' etc
Muenchen is my favourite and no, I have never been to the Oktoberfest
Actually I was the Geschäftsführer of a company in Munich and although German formalities are plenty, it's not a quarter as bad as dealing with the IRS where anything can happen
I had to swear to uphold the laws of Germany before a senior legal official. He had a Bobby Charlton hair do - a wisp of hair that curled right round his head but otherwise totally bald
He was introduced to me in a very formal setting as 'Herr Bender' and I nearly choked. I can remember the sheer effort of holding back the tears
#44
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
Oh wow, that is like the time I visted Japan. They want you to register for a gaijin card and carry your passport around at all times. But I am an English Canadian dual citizen, and I wonder what category I would fit, since I am also a British citizen, thus a member of the EU! Would I be a foreigner or fellow member?
However, the PPs are right, it is required. So I now carry a photocopy of it because I refuse to risk losing my British Passport.. simply too expensive to replace! Don't know really if that fulfills my duty to carry ID but so far so good
#45
Just Joined
Joined: Jan 2010
Location: Hamburg
Posts: 10
Re: Is ID really compulsory all the time in Germany?
To finally put this one to bed. You must have valid identification when resident in Germany, ie a valid (non-expired) UK passport BUT you do not have to carry it with you at all times. Of course, it may be sensible to have id (or a photocopy) with you just in case you need to prove you are who you say you are it is not required by law.