Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
#16
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Nov 2012
Location: bute
Posts: 9,740
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
"Paid his dues"? You do not understand how health cover works.
Many British citizens just assume that "Abroad" will provide NHS-type cover. Not so. there is a huge amount of information available online now. If you can read and have basic computer search skills you can find out what the position is. Ignorance of the rules is not a defence.
Many British citizens just assume that "Abroad" will provide NHS-type cover. Not so. there is a huge amount of information available online now. If you can read and have basic computer search skills you can find out what the position is. Ignorance of the rules is not a defence.
Last edited by scot47; Feb 7th 2018 at 2:44 am.
#17
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Philosophically you may be correct, but the system doesn't work that way. Each country in Europe has its own way of qualifying for, and paying for health insurance, and with very limited exceptions (typically where a national government agrees to pay for Healthcare in another country), having "paid in" in one country doesn't entitle you to health treatment in another country.
#18
Forum Regular
Joined: Apr 2014
Location: Northern California
Posts: 53
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
What interests me is the period between the time you arrive in France with S1 in hand and the time when your application for a CV is processed by the French authorities. You are in France with an S1, so that means no longer covered by the NHS but without a CV. Are you stuck in limbo and therefore uninsured ?
#19
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2012
Location: Dépt 61
Posts: 5,254
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
What interests me is the period between the time you arrive in France with S1 in hand and the time when your application for a CV is processed by the French authorities. You are in France with an S1, so that means no longer covered by the NHS but without a CV. Are you stuck in limbo and therefore uninsured ?
If you apply to join the health system as an inactif without an S1, it does take a while and many people take out private health insurance to cover the gap. Alternatively, you can probably get away with using your EHIC if necessary for the first 3 months because the UK doesn't know you've left, and if you're accepted your application will normally be backdated to the date you applied so if you're sure you'll be accepted, you might be prepared to pay upfront and wait to be reimbursed part of the cost.
Freedom of movement doesn't mean everyone can go and live wherever they like, there are conditions attached, and one of the conditions for living in France is that you need to have healthcare in place so that you don't become a burden on the state.
I take your point that he's paid his dues in the UK, but that doesn't help France balance its books if he's never paid anything here and the UK won't reimbuse the costs. The French health service is good, but the money has to come from somewhere. Most of us that live here pay a lot in contributions to be able to use it.
In theory if he owns property France can reclaim any costs due against that, you may have to negotiate.
Last edited by EuroTrash; Feb 7th 2018 at 6:28 am.
#20
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
To the OP,
The hospital in Toulouse is certainly Purpan. Do you have their phone number? Have you, or are you able to speak to your Dad? If absolutely necessary I could follow this up briefly on your behalf. I'll be in Blagnac (close to Purpan) one afternoon next week if required.
The hospital in Toulouse is certainly Purpan. Do you have their phone number? Have you, or are you able to speak to your Dad? If absolutely necessary I could follow this up briefly on your behalf. I'll be in Blagnac (close to Purpan) one afternoon next week if required.
#21
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Apr 2008
Location: Hérault (34)
Posts: 8,888
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Not sure tbh - He's of the school whereby you don't go the the quacks unless you're dragged there. I know he did access the healthcare system a year and a half back due to a fall (twisted up ankle) and has done for another fall (bruised back bones). I assumed it had been dealt with by the hospital who had claimed off the NHS but appears I am woefully ignorant to the ways of French Healthcare for European citizens.
As stated, your Dad really should have got into the French Social Security System or taken out private healthcare insurance long ago.
According to French Law, children are financially responsible for their parents' welfare and you and possible siblings may well have to pay any Hospital (and possibly Ambulance and other) bills if he can't pay upfront.
His circumstances aren't clear - has he been filing French Income Tax Declarations since he became resident? (all worldwide income must be declared, wherever it happens to be taxed) He obviously hasn't been paying "Côtisations" (S.S. Contributions), and it sounds as though he's been living under the radar all this time....
TP very kindly offered to make enquiries at Purpan, but the Accounts Dept. might not offer much info to non-family. Have you got siblings in the UK (or Europe) who could look into the problem on the spot?
P.S. The after-care costs (nurses, carers, physiotherapists, home help if he lives alone ....) should also be considered if he hasn't got coverage....
Hope you get everything sorted quickly, it's bad enough having a distant parent in hospital, and none of you need a financial issue, to boot.
#22
Account Closed
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Corky33 mentioned the SSAFA in France and provided their phone number. In case you missed it that is the Armed Forces Charity. Their number in UK is 0800 7314880. They may be able to help at least with contacting the French organisation on your/his behalf in case there is anything they can do. Good luck with it all.
#23
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
What interests me is the period between the time you arrive in France with S1 in hand and the time when your application for a CV is processed by the French authorities. You are in France with an S1, so that means no longer covered by the NHS but without a CV. Are you stuck in limbo and therefore uninsured ?
#24
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Not really true, he has paid in the UK and that covers him for treatment in the UK as a RESIDENT, it does not cover him for treatment in any other country because each country has totally different rules, if he had been a state pensioner he could have returned to the UK and been treated via the NHS, but to get reciprocal treatment in France he would have had to have an S1 form, which id only available for those of STATE pension age, even that does NOT give FREE treatment but just treatment in the same way that people of that age would get in the country they live in. Paying into the UK system gives no rights to people not of pension age living in any other EU country, in the same way as it doesn't for people from the EU living in the UK. The EHIC card is for people VISITING another EU country and gives limited rights, emergency treatment etc. He has, unfortunately, shot himself in the foot as to getting treatment in France, his best solution is, as has been suggested earlier, to contact the SSAFA.
#25
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Apr 2008
Location: Hérault (34)
Posts: 8,888
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Corky33 mentioned the SSAFA in France and provided their phone number. In case you missed it that is the Armed Forces Charity. Their number in UK is 0800 7314880. They may be able to help at least with contacting the French organisation on your/his behalf in case there is anything they can do. Good luck with it all.
All the best to all concerned.
#26
Just Joined
Joined: Aug 2013
Location: Brittany
Posts: 17
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Sorry I should have put +33 but the number I gave is correct and I have checked it with the SSAFA Website. You can also ring SSAFA UK on +44 207 463 9354. I am sure they will be able to give you good advice.
#27
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Apr 2008
Location: Hérault (34)
Posts: 8,888
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
For what it's worth, the départements corresponding to numbers beginning with 05 53 are Dordogne and Lot & Garonne.
Whatever, the OP will be more comfortable ringing the UK number...
#28
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2017
Location: Alicante
Posts: 928
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Assuming your paperwork is in order that can be delivered in as little as a few days and will be backdated to the date of the application so any treatment or medication received in the interim can be reclaimed by submitting the receipts.
BTW and not wishing to pry, if it's a cancer issue then it would be worth contacting Cancersupportfrance.org who are there precisely for such things.
Last edited by Notdunroamin; Feb 7th 2018 at 7:07 pm.
#29
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed
Not sure tbh - He's of the school whereby you don't go the the quacks unless you're dragged there. I know he did access the healthcare system a year and a half back due to a fall (twisted up ankle) and has done for another fall (bruised back bones). I assumed it had been dealt with by the hospital who had claimed off the NHS but appears I am woefully ignorant to the ways of French Healthcare for European citizens.
#30
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 84
Re: Dad in hospital in France/ Advice needed