Poland considerations
#1
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2013
Location: Chicago
Posts: 470
Poland considerations
My spouse is Polish with Polish citizenship, and with us in retirement we’re considering moving to her homeland for familiarity and common culture. It was actually deciding between UK and Poland, with both still viable.
The issue is that Poland has really changed since 1982 when she left and where we met. Not just economically from those east bloc communist days, but as a political culture. I guess this applies also to Hungary, but it’s become a rightwing, heavily religious society where democracy and tolerance is under threat.
I was wondering if anyone else had these concerns in their consideration of resettling in Eastern Europe. From what I’ve read, Czechia and Slovakia are not far behind in this Trump-like move to the right. Maybe the politics there can be ignored, but I’m really not sure.
The issue is that Poland has really changed since 1982 when she left and where we met. Not just economically from those east bloc communist days, but as a political culture. I guess this applies also to Hungary, but it’s become a rightwing, heavily religious society where democracy and tolerance is under threat.
I was wondering if anyone else had these concerns in their consideration of resettling in Eastern Europe. From what I’ve read, Czechia and Slovakia are not far behind in this Trump-like move to the right. Maybe the politics there can be ignored, but I’m really not sure.
#2
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Poland considerations
My spouse is Polish with Polish citizenship, and with us in retirement we’re considering moving to her homeland for familiarity and common culture. It was actually deciding between UK and Poland, with both still viable.
The issue is that Poland has really changed since 1982 when she left and where we met. Not just economically from those east bloc communist days, but as a political culture. I guess this applies also to Hungary, but it’s become a rightwing, heavily religious society where democracy and tolerance is under threat.
I was wondering if anyone else had these concerns in their consideration of resettling in Eastern Europe. From what I’ve read, Czechia and Slovakia are not far behind in this Trump-like move to the right. Maybe the politics there can be ignored, but I’m really not sure.
The issue is that Poland has really changed since 1982 when she left and where we met. Not just economically from those east bloc communist days, but as a political culture. I guess this applies also to Hungary, but it’s become a rightwing, heavily religious society where democracy and tolerance is under threat.
I was wondering if anyone else had these concerns in their consideration of resettling in Eastern Europe. From what I’ve read, Czechia and Slovakia are not far behind in this Trump-like move to the right. Maybe the politics there can be ignored, but I’m really not sure.
#3
Re: Poland considerations
Hi Richard,
I have lived in Warsaw since late 2000.
I wouldn't recommend basing a decision to move to Poland on the current political situation here. While I am no fan of the current administration, the last lot were no saints either.
In general I don't notice much of an impact from them on day-to-day life.
In terms of society being more or less rightwing/tolerant/religious etc I don't see things being any different now than at any other time in the 17 years that I have been here.
I have a young family and certainly feel safe bringing them up here; safer than back in the UK.
My views are based on life in Warsaw and perhaps things are different in smaller towns or villages.
Hope that helps.
Ross.
I have lived in Warsaw since late 2000.
I wouldn't recommend basing a decision to move to Poland on the current political situation here. While I am no fan of the current administration, the last lot were no saints either.
In general I don't notice much of an impact from them on day-to-day life.
In terms of society being more or less rightwing/tolerant/religious etc I don't see things being any different now than at any other time in the 17 years that I have been here.
I have a young family and certainly feel safe bringing them up here; safer than back in the UK.
My views are based on life in Warsaw and perhaps things are different in smaller towns or villages.
Hope that helps.
Ross.
#4
On a grand tour
Joined: Jul 2017
Location: Somewhere dusty
Posts: 240
Re: Poland considerations
Methinks you're placing too much store by the hysterical doom-mongers of the Guardian, NYT, etc.
"rightwing" - it depends how you define that, and whether you consider that intrinsically more wicked than being "left-wing".
"heavily religious" - these countries tend to be more religious than Western Europe is, yes. It's just one of the shared things that shape and bind the populations together in a sense of community.
"democracy and tolerance under threat" - no sign of that at all, other than the storm-in-a-teacup about the current government wanting to remove some judges (who were installed at the last minute by the outgoing government).
I'm also considering one of these countries in the longer term, and regard their tendency to look after their own people, culture and nation first - even at the risk of contravening current orthodoxies - and refusing to be bullied by more powerful neighbours, as a feature, not a bug.
"rightwing" - it depends how you define that, and whether you consider that intrinsically more wicked than being "left-wing".
"heavily religious" - these countries tend to be more religious than Western Europe is, yes. It's just one of the shared things that shape and bind the populations together in a sense of community.
"democracy and tolerance under threat" - no sign of that at all, other than the storm-in-a-teacup about the current government wanting to remove some judges (who were installed at the last minute by the outgoing government).
I'm also considering one of these countries in the longer term, and regard their tendency to look after their own people, culture and nation first - even at the risk of contravening current orthodoxies - and refusing to be bullied by more powerful neighbours, as a feature, not a bug.
#5
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2013
Location: Chicago
Posts: 470
Re: Poland considerations
Thanks all for the perspectives on this. Especially Ross, actually on the scene in Warsaw. Yes, I’m probably taking a bit of an exaggerated point of view. But we’ve seen the impact of Donald Trump here, and it has not been pretty. Civil discourse is not what it used to be and is divisive like never before.
And to tooboocoo’s point, yes I’d prefer living in a left leaning country than right. Again, also based on what we’re witnessing here. But then, the culture is different there and maybe not fair to compare in the same way.
Expatrick, it seems like an Eastern European trend, and noting out of interest.
And to tooboocoo’s point, yes I’d prefer living in a left leaning country than right. Again, also based on what we’re witnessing here. But then, the culture is different there and maybe not fair to compare in the same way.
Expatrick, it seems like an Eastern European trend, and noting out of interest.
Last edited by Richard8655; Mar 1st 2018 at 11:35 am.
#6
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Poland considerations
Might be worth reconsidering the UK, good chance of a Labour Govt. in the next few years!
#7
On a grand tour
Joined: Jul 2017
Location: Somewhere dusty
Posts: 240
Re: Poland considerations
To each his own - if you prefer a left-leaning environment, fair enough.
There's Canada, Ireland, the UK, and most of W Europe and Scandinavia to choose from, so plenty of choice for you. But those societies are also being profoundly changed, by their very tolerance and openness.
As an aside, I would posit that civil discourse in the USA took a turn for the worse long before Donald Trump ever thought of running for office.
There's Canada, Ireland, the UK, and most of W Europe and Scandinavia to choose from, so plenty of choice for you. But those societies are also being profoundly changed, by their very tolerance and openness.
As an aside, I would posit that civil discourse in the USA took a turn for the worse long before Donald Trump ever thought of running for office.
#8
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2013
Location: Chicago
Posts: 470
Re: Poland considerations
To each his own - if you prefer a left-leaning environment, fair enough.
There's Canada, Ireland, the UK, and most of W Europe and Scandinavia to choose from, so plenty of choice for you. But those societies are also being profoundly changed, by their very tolerance and openness.
As an aside, I would posit that civil discourse in the USA took a turn for the worse long before Donald Trump ever thought of running for office.
There's Canada, Ireland, the UK, and most of W Europe and Scandinavia to choose from, so plenty of choice for you. But those societies are also being profoundly changed, by their very tolerance and openness.
As an aside, I would posit that civil discourse in the USA took a turn for the worse long before Donald Trump ever thought of running for office.
#9
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Poland considerations
Good to hear chances are improving.
I think you'll find it does, just not in the way you might expect. Religion in daily life here is as much about heritage as it is about theology, although there are of course many practising adherents.
Last edited by scrubbedexpat142; Mar 1st 2018 at 2:11 pm.
#10
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2013
Location: Chicago
Posts: 470
Re: Poland considerations
Yes, somewhat true. But I'm sure not quite as overt and on display in the UK. I'm thinking pilgrimage marches, ban on abortion, in vitro restrictions, and similar that wouldn't be seen with the Anglican Church in the UK.
#11
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Poland considerations
Edited to add: You're right in one sense, in the UK, active, vocal opposition to "established" views on "sensitive" issues has been heavily suppressed, lest one be labelled an "ist" or a "phobic".
Last edited by scrubbedexpat142; Mar 1st 2018 at 4:01 pm.
#12
Just Joined
Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 25
Re: Poland considerations
I've lived in poland on and off for the last number of years in both big towns and small villages. I find that politics here can be mostly ignored to some degree but they do exist and is also religious like they most recent idea is no working on Sunday so now most stores are closed on sunday.
Nothing major that i think would impact quality of life.
Other hurdles would getting paperwork in order like getting pesel and opening a bank account as a foreigner you will get the run around and wait in long queues.
Mostly Poland is a nice place that isnt so overly political or difficult for foreigners.
Nothing major that i think would impact quality of life.
Other hurdles would getting paperwork in order like getting pesel and opening a bank account as a foreigner you will get the run around and wait in long queues.
Mostly Poland is a nice place that isnt so overly political or difficult for foreigners.
#13
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2013
Location: Chicago
Posts: 470
Re: Poland considerations
I've lived in poland on and off for the last number of years in both big towns and small villages. I find that politics here can be mostly ignored to some degree but they do exist and is also religious like they most recent idea is no working on Sunday so now most stores are closed on sunday.
Nothing major that i think would impact quality of life.
Other hurdles would getting paperwork in order like getting pesel and opening a bank account as a foreigner you will get the run around and wait in long queues.
Mostly Poland is a nice place that isnt so overly political or difficult for foreigners.
Nothing major that i think would impact quality of life.
Other hurdles would getting paperwork in order like getting pesel and opening a bank account as a foreigner you will get the run around and wait in long queues.
Mostly Poland is a nice place that isnt so overly political or difficult for foreigners.
We’re looking at either Lodz (family reasons) or southern Tatra mountain region of the country. But glad to hear you’re finding life there pretty good.
#14
Just Joined
Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 25
Re: Poland considerations
Yes non citizens will also need pesel if they want to get anything done. Lodz is Nice it's fairly commercial but a good place if your looking for work, I'm not familiar with the tatra region but my wife says it's beautiful, apparently they have their own dialect there also although i imagine it would be difficult to find work around there.