pallykin

somebody Are you working with an immigration attorney?

I had wondered if this was something that might get addressed through the judicial unfairness route.

Laurie Fransman will have a new edition of his book Fransman’s British Nationality Law next September. I expect it will have a lot of judicial unfairness case studies, both successful and unsuccessful in it.

https://www.amazon.com/Fransmans-Bri...s%2C340&sr=8-1

somebody

Yes, and I believe this is the safest route forward for complex claims.

If this is important to you, and it sounds like it is, I would focus on finding the correct professional advisor instead of waiting for the next edition of a book to guide you.

pallykin

I look forward to hearing your news.

It’s my understanding that immigration attorneys refer to Fransman… because this is where precedent can be found.

somebody

pallykin, immigration attorneys do not simply blindly apply Fransman or other texts. They make arguments based on the totality of facts and circumstances.
A British subject child who has lived legally in the UK for over a decade should have the same rights in 1910 as a naturalized British subject child who has lived legally in the UK for over a decade. Romein addresses the historical inability to register.

We will investigate this, but since every case is different I suggest you seek your own legal advice.

pallykin

Having been refused once, I’m looking for that glimmer of hope that suggests it’s worth trying again…

pallykin

somebody, how did your citizenship application go? Or are you still waiting?