FIRES! Is everyone ok?
#166
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
Does anyone know if the man called Sam found his family, I saw that and he was so composed, he looked like he still had so much hope, but it was obvious the friend with him, wasnt so hopeful That was on that morning show, did they update it? Talk about sad you were just willing him to get some good news.
Last I heard was that neighbours had seen her and the kids go back to the house. The house didn't survive, and although not confirmed they believe his family are dead.
I hope someone else has had some news since and I am wrong though.
#167
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
Marysville had around 500 residents. The costs to plan and construct a sufficient number of underground bunkers to accommodate the populations of bushfire affected zones would run into many, many millions of $$$.
Perhaps it is as simple as you suggest though, and we might see the construction of these kind of shelters in years to come.
Perhaps it is as simple as you suggest though, and we might see the construction of these kind of shelters in years to come.
We are about to start on a basement (so similar costings) for less than $100k and it will be 175sqm at a depth of 3 metres.
I think therefore that it should be cost effective (perhaps a FHBG like grant for home owners in the bush?)
#170
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 10,375
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
On the bunker subject, In qld many estates/councils now require water tanks as part of the building code. Often people dont like the look of them, so huge tanks are dug in, under the house, quite common.
Its not that costly if done at excavation, ( well unless you have a load of rock, etc ) if that can be included in the building code, they could easily enforce bunkers. I guess the problem was ( up till now ) people just didnt believe how fast/huge/dangerous/unpredictable bush fires are.
Its not that costly if done at excavation, ( well unless you have a load of rock, etc ) if that can be included in the building code, they could easily enforce bunkers. I guess the problem was ( up till now ) people just didnt believe how fast/huge/dangerous/unpredictable bush fires are.
#171
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
http://cosmos.bcst.yahoo.com/up/play...7lifestyle&ch=
#172
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
#173
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 10,375
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
Watched the Sam update, thanks poor man, so many tragedies, but he just stuck in my mind as he seemed so hopeful they were still up there alive.
#175
Forum Regular
Joined: Feb 2008
Location: Lorne. Victoria
Posts: 74
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
There are effectively town bunkers at the moment. In Kinglake you could have gone to the CFA shed or the Police station. The problem is still whether you can still get there without getting caught in the car. If you live 10 mins outside of the town centre then you could be in trouble.
Personally, if I lived up there I would have a bunker (doubling as a store room). I reckon you could build one for a $1k or less if you did the work yourself. Dig a hole. Line it with tin roofing material. Some strong beams for the roof. More tin and cover with a couple of inches of soil. I don't think oxygen is a problem. Fire suffocation is usually caused by smoke or CO rather than lack of oxygen. CO shouldn't be a problem as it's in the open. The fire should be drawing in air at ground level so you should have enough oxygen. I'd try and have the door facing East as that's the most unlikely direction for the fire to come from.
The problem I can see with legislation is to whom it should apply. Many of Mellie's outer suburbs have a lot of bush but the inner suburbs don't. Where do you draw the line?
When we came to Mellie we were originally thinking of living in the Dandenongs but after a couple of days we decided (amongst other reasons) that the fire risk was too high.
I reckon the government should do more education on this rather than legislation. I think that most Victorians have been woefully unaware of the dangers of bushfires.
Personally, if I lived up there I would have a bunker (doubling as a store room). I reckon you could build one for a $1k or less if you did the work yourself. Dig a hole. Line it with tin roofing material. Some strong beams for the roof. More tin and cover with a couple of inches of soil. I don't think oxygen is a problem. Fire suffocation is usually caused by smoke or CO rather than lack of oxygen. CO shouldn't be a problem as it's in the open. The fire should be drawing in air at ground level so you should have enough oxygen. I'd try and have the door facing East as that's the most unlikely direction for the fire to come from.
The problem I can see with legislation is to whom it should apply. Many of Mellie's outer suburbs have a lot of bush but the inner suburbs don't. Where do you draw the line?
When we came to Mellie we were originally thinking of living in the Dandenongs but after a couple of days we decided (amongst other reasons) that the fire risk was too high.
I reckon the government should do more education on this rather than legislation. I think that most Victorians have been woefully unaware of the dangers of bushfires.
The CFA has for a number of years made fire fighting experts available in our community to give talks and advice on how to survive a bushfire. Preparing the property, what to do before and when the fire front approaches, and what to do after the front passes and this advice has been invaluable. The CFA offers a crucial amount of advice, information and assistance to people living in high risk areas, but this is not always taken up by the public. We have attended many pre-fire season information sessions and in all cases less that ten people have turned up to the meetings and this is in a town of 900 permanent residents, with a very large weekend population, and where the Ash Wednesday fires went raging through in ’83.
If there is a fire in our area, we will stay; it would be suicidal to try and travel into a town 20 minutes drive away through a heavily forested area. We consider we have made a good effort to protect our lives and property to the best of our ability, We know we cannot expect any immediate assistance from the CFA, as they will have their hands filled protecting the township. However we feel safer on our property – with the measures we have taken – than we would in the township and would definitely resist being forced to leave
Our fire bunker cost us around $2000. It was dug into clay and it’s unlined. After 18 months the walls are still damp. We worked with an experienced “bunker” builder and the costs were as follows:
Bunker Builders wages (one week) $1400.00
Cost of digging the hole by a backhoe operator approximately $500.00.
Scoria for the spoon drain around the perimeter of the roof cost $20.00.
We cut down a large tree from the property for the roof beams.
We already had roofing iron spare on the site and we used the soil from the excavation for the final roof covering. We used an ordinary heavy duty door covered with corrugated iron as an entrance door. As the door was underground it did not need to be fireproof. My husband worked for a week with the bunker builder and probably another week or so after that putting in the door and the steps (cut into the clay) down to the bunker entrance. The bunker is 3.5m x 4m and 2.6m deep. The roof is about a metre below the level of the driveway so actually the bunker is 3.6m into the ground.
There is plenty of air in this bunker for a few hours, you only need to be in a bunker for 15 or so minutes, under “normal circumstances” (if you could call a bushfire normal) But with a fire the ferocity of this recent one it may be longer. One thing you have to be aware of in a bunker of this type is, when it‘s not in use always leave the door open. This allows the air to circulate. Iron is used as part of the construction and it can rust and of course the rust will use up the oxygen in the enclosed space.
I don’t really know what the price would be if you had it professionally built, but ours is fine. It’s deep and cool and I feel safe with it.
dalhousie
#176
Account Closed
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 3,821
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
Is there a list or anything compiled or due to be compiled so people can check if someone is missing?
Em x
Em x
#177
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
Last I heard there was just a phone number to ring to find people but you have to hang on for ages obviously.
#178
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
Any idea what time frame maximum one could use? ie too account for the house above and besides to be burnt to the ground?
Was wondering if a sprinkler system mounted through the centre of the house to keep the roof and subsequent external walls would be effective? Hence question of time to see how much water flow would be required?
#179
Re: FIRES! Is everyone ok?
Thanks for that very interesting on your bunker build.
Any idea what time frame maximum one could use? ie too account for the house above and besides to be burnt to the ground?
Was wondering if a sprinkler system mounted through the centre of the house to keep the roof and subsequent external walls would be effective? Hence question of time to see how much water flow would be required?
Any idea what time frame maximum one could use? ie too account for the house above and besides to be burnt to the ground?
Was wondering if a sprinkler system mounted through the centre of the house to keep the roof and subsequent external walls would be effective? Hence question of time to see how much water flow would be required?
Didn't work for poor Sam's family and friends (see video above where you posted the news article to same story of the NZ woman who died). They all went to her house because they had sprinklers, but they all perished - up to 9 people were in there.