Are "plane people" better than "boat people"?
#92
Re: Are "plane people" better than "boat people"?
Agree. The previous government's policy, although not perfect, was better than what is happening now.
We take 13000-odd UNHCR people a year - one of the highest, per capita in the world. I reckon we should take more of them and zero boat people - not one. Make it clear that if you come in by boat, you ain't getting in.
We take 13000-odd UNHCR people a year - one of the highest, per capita in the world. I reckon we should take more of them and zero boat people - not one. Make it clear that if you come in by boat, you ain't getting in.
#93
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Oct 2005
Location: Hill overlooking the SE Melbourne suburbs
Posts: 16,622
#99
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 4,555
Re: Are "plane people" better than "boat people"?
I would prefer we not have to take any but the conflicts in the world make that impossible. Here are the current numbers which do not seem unreasonable
http://www.immi.gov.au/media/fact-sheets/60refugee.htm
#100
Re: Are "plane people" better than "boat people"?
Not everyone who arrives by boat or plane are accepted.
I would prefer we not have to take any but the conflicts in the world make that impossible. Here are the current numbers which do not seem unreasonable
http://www.immi.gov.au/media/fact-sheets/60refugee.htm
I would prefer we not have to take any but the conflicts in the world make that impossible. Here are the current numbers which do not seem unreasonable
http://www.immi.gov.au/media/fact-sheets/60refugee.htm
The UNHCR sends people here who they think are at risk. It is proper and right that we accept these people but we should draw the line there and accept no boat people at all. I would be happy to see a modest increase in the amount of UN people sent here.
#103
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Are "plane people" better than "boat people"?
During 2007–08, 13,014 Humanitarian visas were granted as follows:
5,132 Refugee (subclass 200) visas
5,026 Global Special Humanitarian Program (subclass 202) visas
1,704 Permanent Protection (subclass 866) visas
819 Woman at Risk (subclass 204) visas
196 Temporary Protection (subclass 785) visas
84 Temporary (Humanitarian Concern) (subclass 786) visa
42 In-country Special Humanitarian (subclass 201) visas
6 Secondary Movement Relocation (Temporary) (subclass 451) visas
5 Emergency Rescue (subclass 203) visas
I don't think it is a case of affecting many peoples lifestyles with a reasonable number. But I don't think that the message should be put out to everyone to get on a boat, as you have a guaranteed home in Australia, with regular paypacket for no work. That might just have complications.
5,132 Refugee (subclass 200) visas
5,026 Global Special Humanitarian Program (subclass 202) visas
1,704 Permanent Protection (subclass 866) visas
819 Woman at Risk (subclass 204) visas
196 Temporary Protection (subclass 785) visas
84 Temporary (Humanitarian Concern) (subclass 786) visa
42 In-country Special Humanitarian (subclass 201) visas
6 Secondary Movement Relocation (Temporary) (subclass 451) visas
5 Emergency Rescue (subclass 203) visas
I don't think it is a case of affecting many peoples lifestyles with a reasonable number. But I don't think that the message should be put out to everyone to get on a boat, as you have a guaranteed home in Australia, with regular paypacket for no work. That might just have complications.
#104
BE Enthusiast
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 303
Re: Are "plane people" better than "boat people"?
During 2007–08, 13,014 Humanitarian visas were granted as follows:
5,132 Refugee (subclass 200) visas
5,026 Global Special Humanitarian Program (subclass 202) visas
1,704 Permanent Protection (subclass 866) visas
819 Woman at Risk (subclass 204) visas
196 Temporary Protection (subclass 785) visas
84 Temporary (Humanitarian Concern) (subclass 786) visa
42 In-country Special Humanitarian (subclass 201) visas
6 Secondary Movement Relocation (Temporary) (subclass 451) visas
5 Emergency Rescue (subclass 203) visas
I don't think it is a case of affecting many peoples lifestyles with a reasonable number. But I don't think that the message should be put out to everyone to get on a boat, as you have a guaranteed home in Australia, with regular paypacket for no work. That might just have complications.
5,132 Refugee (subclass 200) visas
5,026 Global Special Humanitarian Program (subclass 202) visas
1,704 Permanent Protection (subclass 866) visas
819 Woman at Risk (subclass 204) visas
196 Temporary Protection (subclass 785) visas
84 Temporary (Humanitarian Concern) (subclass 786) visa
42 In-country Special Humanitarian (subclass 201) visas
6 Secondary Movement Relocation (Temporary) (subclass 451) visas
5 Emergency Rescue (subclass 203) visas
I don't think it is a case of affecting many peoples lifestyles with a reasonable number. But I don't think that the message should be put out to everyone to get on a boat, as you have a guaranteed home in Australia, with regular paypacket for no work. That might just have complications.
#105
Re: Are "plane people" better than "boat people"?
During 2007–08, 13,014 Humanitarian visas were granted as follows:
5,132 Refugee (subclass 200) visas
5,026 Global Special Humanitarian Program (subclass 202) visas
1,704 Permanent Protection (subclass 866) visas
819 Woman at Risk (subclass 204) visas
196 Temporary Protection (subclass 785) visas
84 Temporary (Humanitarian Concern) (subclass 786) visa
42 In-country Special Humanitarian (subclass 201) visas
6 Secondary Movement Relocation (Temporary) (subclass 451) visas
5 Emergency Rescue (subclass 203) visas
I don't think it is a case of affecting many peoples lifestyles with a reasonable number. But I don't think that the message should be put out to everyone to get on a boat, as you have a guaranteed home in Australia, with regular paypacket for no work. That might just have complications.
5,132 Refugee (subclass 200) visas
5,026 Global Special Humanitarian Program (subclass 202) visas
1,704 Permanent Protection (subclass 866) visas
819 Woman at Risk (subclass 204) visas
196 Temporary Protection (subclass 785) visas
84 Temporary (Humanitarian Concern) (subclass 786) visa
42 In-country Special Humanitarian (subclass 201) visas
6 Secondary Movement Relocation (Temporary) (subclass 451) visas
5 Emergency Rescue (subclass 203) visas
I don't think it is a case of affecting many peoples lifestyles with a reasonable number. But I don't think that the message should be put out to everyone to get on a boat, as you have a guaranteed home in Australia, with regular paypacket for no work. That might just have complications.